I have often maintained that the fringe group Australians for Palestine is not about supporting Palestine or Palestinians at all.
The AFP site is carrying a story taken from the Maan Newsagency entitled "Dutch ministry advises businesses to label settlement products", The Maan story carries a photograph of two men wearing polo tops with a slogan in Arabic.
The AFP site has done away with the Maan picture and has run with this instead -
You can draw your own conclusions.
Wednesday, March 13, 2013
Monday, March 11, 2013
HOPES OF TRUTH FAIL AT THE AGE
A BBC snapshot of the bereaved father of a Palestinian child killed firing Operation Pillar of Defence. Human Rights Watch and other pro Palestinian groups automatically blamed Israel. A UN report has now concluded the death was due to Hamas rocket fire.
Reporters of the conflict between Israel and its Arab neighbours know full well the impact of footage of innocent children caught up in war can have to elicit sympathy for one side. After all, it was the graphic vision of the death of young Mohammed Al-Dura at the outset of the Second Palestinian intifada that not only enflamed the Muslim world but garnered much international sympathy for the Palestinians and hatred towards the Israelis. The rage continued even when it became clear that it was unlikely that the Israeli army was not responsible for the death and in that respect, the media also played its role by ignoring the truth.
This scenario has played itself out on numerous occasions and last year we saw photographs of eleven year olds A’hd Tamimi, and her cousin Marah Tamimi on the front pages of Fairfax media outlets alongside an article charging the Israeli army with the routine abuse of Palestinian children. A caption in the Age said "An Israeli soldier restrains a Palestinian girl crying over the arrest of her mother during a protest over land confiscation in al-Nabi Saleh." It turned out that the two were children of well know Palestinian activists and were being used as props in a campaign against Israel, encouraged by their parents to be exactly where they were. They were being put in harm's way in a cynical attempt to garner international sympathy for the cause of delegitimising Israel.
Despite being caught with its pants down, Fairfax Media persisted. During Israel’s recent war with Hamas, its now Palestinian based reporter Ruth Pollard reported as follows in Hopes of truce fail as Israel and Hamas remain defiant
But don't hold your breath waiting for an apology from Pollard or HRW.
Reporters of the conflict between Israel and its Arab neighbours know full well the impact of footage of innocent children caught up in war can have to elicit sympathy for one side. After all, it was the graphic vision of the death of young Mohammed Al-Dura at the outset of the Second Palestinian intifada that not only enflamed the Muslim world but garnered much international sympathy for the Palestinians and hatred towards the Israelis. The rage continued even when it became clear that it was unlikely that the Israeli army was not responsible for the death and in that respect, the media also played its role by ignoring the truth.
This scenario has played itself out on numerous occasions and last year we saw photographs of eleven year olds A’hd Tamimi, and her cousin Marah Tamimi on the front pages of Fairfax media outlets alongside an article charging the Israeli army with the routine abuse of Palestinian children. A caption in the Age said "An Israeli soldier restrains a Palestinian girl crying over the arrest of her mother during a protest over land confiscation in al-Nabi Saleh." It turned out that the two were children of well know Palestinian activists and were being used as props in a campaign against Israel, encouraged by their parents to be exactly where they were. They were being put in harm's way in a cynical attempt to garner international sympathy for the cause of delegitimising Israel.
Despite being caught with its pants down, Fairfax Media persisted. During Israel’s recent war with Hamas, its now Palestinian based reporter Ruth Pollard reported as follows in Hopes of truce fail as Israel and Hamas remain defiant
The devastated family of the BBC journalist Jihad Misharawi mourned the death of his 11-month-old son Omar, killed along with his sister-in-law when an Israeli mortar shell crashed through their house as the attacks escalated on Thursday.As it happens this has been proven to be yet another lie in the campaign against Israel – UN clears Israel of charge it killed baby in Gaza. Human Rights Watch blamed Israel without the slighest amount of investigation into the incident. It now turns out that it wasn't an Israeli mortar shell at all but an errant Hamas missile.
But don't hold your breath waiting for an apology from Pollard or HRW.
Sunday, March 10, 2013
COMPARE AND CONTRAST
In today's letters section, a piece from one correspondent who reckons Hamas, despite the fact that its "repugnant", should continue its policies of violence and hatred towards Jews because if it doesn't then the Israelis will oppress the Palestinians. Sounds a little confused about the meaning of peace negotiations, doesn't he?
Sole bargaining chip
Paul McGeough rightly focused on an important issue - the conditions imposed on Hamas before the Western powers will negotiate with it (''Hamas chief opens up but stays defiant'', 3/3).
While it sounds reasonable to, among other things, ask Hamas to renounce violence and recognise Israel, it should be realised that these are the sole bargaining chips that Hamas has. Once these concessions are made, Israel has what it wants and does not need to offer any concessions of its own. It can continue to oppress the Palestinians and proceed with its progressive theft of Palestinian land, while stonewalling in any negotiations.
Hamas is a repugnant organisation, but that doesn't prevent its leader speaking the truth occasionally.
GREG PLATT, Brunswick
Then there's this view that sums it up so much better.
Nothing has changed
Folksy photographs of Hamas leader Khalid Mishal belie the fact that nothing has changed: Hamas is a still a terrorist organisation whose charter formally calls for the genocide of a neighbouring country (Israel), and whose military wing routinely attempts suicide and rocket attacks to further this aim. Mishal's view of the region may well include himself as leader of the Palestinian people, but it also includes the eradication of Israel.
ALAN FREEDMAN, St Kilda East
Saturday, March 09, 2013
Sheridan gets it right: Carr & Rudd get it completely wrong
If you have read the perversion of the facts of the sad case of Ben Zygier as presented in the Fairfax Media, then get today's Oz where Greg Sheridan, by contrast really nails the truth.
Bob Carr and Kevin Rudd completely wrong on Israel
THE sad case of Ben Zygier, the Mossad agent who committed suicide in an Israeli prison in 2010, brings to the fore the strange pathologies in Australian opinion concerning Israel.He's no doubt referring to the likes of Ruth Pollard before going on to deal with Rudd and Carr:
It also underlines how badly the Labor government has gone off course in its conception of Israel, and Israel's place in the world.
Beyond Zygier, let me offer some examples of where Labor has got it wrong on Israel and then suggest the analytical mistake at the root of these missteps. Last year in a cabinet revolt, Julia Gillard was overridden on a key UN vote. Australia was set to vote no to elevating the status of the Palestinian Authority to an observer state at the UN. Carr and Rudd opposed Gillard's position (though Rudd was not a player in this vote). Under the baleful influence of Gareth Evans, a tremendously negative force on contemporary Labor foreign policy who offers only a bureaucratic version of conventional wisdom (and conventional wisdom is often wrong), Canberra changed its vote and abstained. In its own terms, this was a very bad move. There will never be a resolution to the Israeli-Palestinian dispute until both sides compromise over an agreement. This UN move, along with many tens of millions of dollars of increased Australian aid to the Palestinians, gives them something for nothing. It helps convince the Palestinian leadership that the way to success doesn't involve compromise and negotiation. Instead the international community will do their job for them. It is a destructive syndrome. ... Israel is Australia's friend and ally. The Labor Party used to know this and care about it. Joining in the popular kicking of Israel is not a sign of moral courage, though it will win plaudits from the usual suspects at the UN and in conventional international relations think tanks.
Friday, March 08, 2013
Thursday, February 28, 2013
LETTER OF THE WEEK
Today's Sydney Morning Herald
(Loyalty disparaged
Bill Tango (Letters, February 27) is quite right: to say there is a possibility of a conflict of loyalties for an individual with dual Australian-Israeli citizenship is not veiled antisemitism. But to exploit the issue to cast aspersions on the loyalties of Australian Jews as a whole is.
Peter Wertheim Executive Director, Executive Council of Australian Jewry
Bill Tango (Letters, February 27) is quite right: to say there is a possibility of a conflict of loyalties for an individual with dual Australian-Israeli citizenship is not veiled antisemitism. But to exploit the issue to cast aspersions on the loyalties of Australian Jews as a whole is.
Peter Wertheim Executive Director, Executive Council of Australian Jewry
Sunday, February 24, 2013
Report: Israel informed Australia when Zygier was arrested
It seems that a former Age journo may have played a role in the death of Ben Zygier.
Report: Israel informed Australia when Zygier was arrested
Report: Israel informed Australia when Zygier was arrested
Saturday, February 23, 2013
Back to Dreyfus
"Clearly
the Mossad has no monopoly on the use of foreign passports for
espionage, but it seems clear that because it’s the Mossad and not the
CIA, and because Ben Zygier was a Jew, that the affair has been referred
to in terms of a 'betrayal' or 'double dealing.'"
Assault on Australian Jewry
Assault on Australian Jewry
Wednesday, January 30, 2013
LETTER OF THE WEEK
In today's OZ-
Perhaps the Malaysian Prime Minister's visit to Hamas-controlled
Gaza was a meeting to compare human rights violations and abuses ("An
unwise Hamas dalliance", 29/1). If anything, Hamas is a world leader in
this area.
Joel Feren, Elwood, Vic
Hamas leads the way
MALAYSIA'S human rights track record is not too flash. It allows for detention without trial and strongly restrict freedom of the press.Joel Feren, Elwood, Vic
Monday, December 24, 2012
Murder at the Bakery
This is the handiwork of Bashar al-Assad
Friend of Hizbullah
Friend of Hamas
Whoever supports these butchers is a murderer himself.
Friend of Hizbullah
Friend of Hamas
Whoever supports these butchers is a murderer himself.
Sunday, December 23, 2012
Incredible news from the Age!!!
The Age is running a story today entitled '124-year-old' Arab-Israeli woman dies.
The incredible part of the story is that the Israelis haven't been blamed for her death and the story doesn't mention the occupation, settlements or the security fence.
A truly amazing piece of journalism coming from this newspaper.
The incredible part of the story is that the Israelis haven't been blamed for her death and the story doesn't mention the occupation, settlements or the security fence.
A truly amazing piece of journalism coming from this newspaper.
Friday, December 21, 2012
When?
When are we going to see a cartoon in the Age depicting Hamas supporting Hizbullah helping Assad butcher women and children in Damascus?
They're coming for the Palestinians over there, you know?
Saturday, December 15, 2012
LETTER OF THE WEEK
This week's letter of the week is the second one.
The first letter is your typical senseless fawning piece of meaningless drivel that always seems to get published in the Age when Leunig comes under attack for one of his offensive assaults on the Jews. Let's hope that Malcolm Chalmers never has to see the reflection of an Iranian made missile coming at him in his mirror.
LEUNIG holds a mirror up to society. Those who condemn the cartoonist don't like, or fear, the reflections.
Malcolm Chalmers, Cleveland, Qld
Well said, Nick Dyrenfurth. Sadly, Leunig has become the cartoon.
Beata Fisher, Toorak
Friday, December 14, 2012
Subliminal
The Age seems to have woken up to itself and allowed a response to Leunig's obscenities which it tried to pass of as art.
The opinion piece by Nick Dyrenfurth Leunig, your provocative use of Nazi analogies is so tiresome is well written, well thought out and covers all the bases but he's being far too polite and probably taking into account the cartoonist's unusual sensibilities.
Not to mention that if he went any further, the Age probably wouldn't publish it or would heavily censor it as it has done recently with other correspondence about its favourite resident Jew basher cartoonist.
The opinion piece by Nick Dyrenfurth Leunig, your provocative use of Nazi analogies is so tiresome is well written, well thought out and covers all the bases but he's being far too polite and probably taking into account the cartoonist's unusual sensibilities.
Not to mention that if he went any further, the Age probably wouldn't publish it or would heavily censor it as it has done recently with other correspondence about its favourite resident Jew basher cartoonist.
And Leunig is not only a Jew basher from way back but he has a record of trying to justify his attacks with gobbledygook, like this rant from back in 2006 - Australian cartoonist on Israel.
When I first read the headline I swear I thought it said Australian con artist on Israel and, as I read through his rambling duck drek of a foamy mouthed rant, I couldn't help but be amused (which is what good cartoonists aspire to, isn't it).
I mean, get a load of his final paragraph:-
So there you have it. Leunig is not only a nasty piece of work and a hypocrite to boot but by his own admission, he's an idiot too!If society no longer wants troublesome, disturbing cartoonists who take improbable positions, so be it. But let's not hear any more of Pastor Martin Neimoller's lament: "First they came for the Jews and I did not speak out because I was not a Jew." What sort of a person will dare to speak out? Probably not a perfect one. Maybe even an idiot.
Thursday, December 13, 2012
The Full Israeli Experience
New York Times columnist Thomas Friedman, who I mentioned on Monday in a piece on Age cartoon artist Leunig is not averse to criticising Israeli policies from titme to time.
He has however, written this insightful piece The Full Israeli Experience
He has however, written this insightful piece The Full Israeli Experience
How does a country deal with failed or failing state authority on four of its borders — Gaza, South Lebanon, Syria and the Sinai Desert of Egypt — each of which is now crawling with nonstate actors nested among civilians and armed with rockets. How should Israel and its friends think about this “Israeli experience” and connect it with the ever-present question of Israeli-Palestinian peace?
What a pity it is
that the many so-called experts on the conflict simply won't understand the complexities
of the situation and the nasty neighborhood within which Israel, for all of its
faults, stands out as a beacon of democracy?
Wednesday, December 12, 2012
Comparing Nazis to Israelis is unacceptable (except at Fairfax Media and in anti-Semitic circles)
If the Age newspaper wasn't covering for its Jew bashing cartoonist Leunig this excellent response from Anti-Defamation Commission chairman Dvir Abramovich is to the Fairfax Media anti-semitic cartoon scandal would have been published in its own pages and not in today's Australian -
Comparing Nazis to Israelis is unacceptable
The Anti-Defamation Commission, a human rights organisation, felt that it could not tolerate such inexcusable expression.Thanks to the Australian for being decent enough to open those doors.
It asked The Age for an opportunity to provide a balancing response to Leunig's cartoon after it was directly attacked in another opinion piece that saw nothing troubling about Leunig's cartoon and instead accused the Jewish community of thoughtlessness and bitterness.
The ADC was told that The Age would not publish its objections because its claims about the cartoon were unreasonable.
So Leunig's "First they came for the Palestinians" is OK while offering a counterpoint is unreasonable.
Leunig accuses the Jewish community of closing doors.
That is exactly what The Age did.
THEY TELL LIES DON'T THEY?
On the very day on which it published cartoonist Michael Leunig's pithy explanation as to why he discriminates against an Israel which defends its citizens against the war crimes of Palestinian terrorism, this item also appeared in the Age: Netanyahu denounces 'deafening silence' on Hamas.
In case anyone has any doubts about Meshal's message, this news quote says it all: Hamas leader vows never to recognize Israel.Speaking to foreign reporters, Mr Netanyahu accused the international community of double standards, condemning settlements that have not yet been built in the West Bank while standing quiet during a historic visit to the Gaza Strip by the exiled leader of Hamas, Khaled Meshal.Making his first trip to the Hamas-ruled territory at the weekend, Mr Meshal delivered a series of speeches to throngs of supporters vowing to wipe Israel off the map. The visit underscored the rising clout of Hamas and regional acceptance since its eight-day conflict with Israel last month.Mr Netanyahu also directed his anger at the Palestinian President, Mahmoud Abbas, for not speaking out."This weekend the leader of Hamas, sitting next to the Hamas leader of Gaza, a man who praised Osama Bin Laden, this weekend openly called for the destruction of Israel. Where was the outrage? Where were the UN resolutions? Where was President Abbas?" Mr Netanyahu asked.
This is the same Meshaal who last month was interviewed by CNN's Christiane Amanpour and lied:GAZA: Hamas leader Khaled Meshaal, making his first ever visit to the Gaza Strip, vowed on Saturday never to recognize Israel and said his Islamist group would never abandon its claim to all Israeli territory.
“Palestine is ours from the river to the sea and from the south to the north. There will be no concession on an inch of the land,” he told a sea of supporters at an open-air rally, the highlight of his three-day stay in Gaza.
“We will never recognize the legitimacy of the Israeli occupation and therefore there is no legitimacy for Israel, no matter how long it will take.”
In the last century another leader who was also an enemy of the Jews lied to the world about his intentions. Only fools like Leunig would accept such treachery to justify their attacks on the only true democracy in the region and its people. Try ducking out of that one!In an exclusive interview with CNN’s, Christiane Amanpour, in the Egyptian Capital, Cairo, head of the Hamas Political Bureau, Khaled Mashal, stated that his movement is not behind the Tel Aviv bombing that took place Wednesday, and confirmed that Hamas accepts a Palestinian State in the 1967 territory, and is willing to join the nonviolent resistance.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

